logo
Recent Comments
  • Janice Clark in The -real- ROI of Social Media?
  • ROI: Statt Zahl… in The -real- ROI of Social Media?
  • Dan G in The -real- ROI of Social Media?
  • Annelies in The -real- ROI of Social Media?
Popular Articles
  • Augmented Reality Semantics (14)
  • The Synaptic Web and the Flux of Information (13)
  • 17 fields of Augmented Reality Applications (10)
  • Upcoming: first Augmented Reality & Virtual Reality all-in-one solution (9)
  • Blog Home
  • Main Site
  • About Us

The Paradox of Choice 2.0

icon1 Posted by Gianluigi Cuccureddu in Management, Marketing on 01 23rd, 2010 | 6 responses

A couple of days ago I was watching a show of a Dutch stand-up comedian, who at one point began talking about the excessive choice consumers are given nowadays. He gave the example of having many kinds of toothpaste, which burdens him, because a person becomes indecisive, whilst the only thing he wants is to have clean teeth and a toothpaste which takes care of that.
When he talked about this topic, sociologist Barry Schwartz came to my mind which wrote the book “The Paradox of Choice: Why More is Less” on customer behavior. In the book he explains that choice overload can lead to decision-making paralysis. Choice is the hallmark of individual freedom and does fit the New Consumer which I referred to in The Axiom of Self-Segmentation , a type of person that seeks authenticity, is individualistic, independent and well-informed.

To give you a short insight in the overwhelming offer, here a part from chapter one “Let’s go shopping” of Schwartz’s book:

A Day at the Supermarket

Scanning the shelves of my local supermarket, recently, I found 85 different varieties andbrands of crackers. As I read the packages, I discovered that some brands had sodium, othersdidn’t. Some were fat-free, others weren’t. They came in big boxes and small ones. They camein normal size and bite size. There were mundane saltines and exotic and expensive imports.

My neighborhood supermarket is not a particularly large store, and yet next to the crackerswere 285 varieties of cookies. Among chocolate chip cookies, there were 21 options. Among“goldfish” (I don’t know whether to count them as cookies or crackers), there were 20 different varieties to choose from. Across the aisle were juices—13 “sports drinks,” 65 “box drinks” for kids, 85 other flavors andbrands of juices, and 75 iced teas and adult drinks. I could get these tea drinks sweetened(sugar or artificial sweetener), lemoned, and flavored. My neighborhood supermarket is not a particularly large store, and yet next to the crackers, were 285 varieties of cookies.
Next, in the snack aisle, there were 95 options in all—chips (taco and potato, ridged and flat, flavored and unflavored, salted and unsalted, high fat, low fat, no fat), pretzels, and the like, including a dozen varieties of “Pringles.” Nearby was seltzer, no doubt to wash down thesnacks. Bubbled water was displayed in at least 15 flavors.

In the pharmaceutical aisles, I found 61 varieties of sun tan oil and sunblock, and 80 differentpain relievers—aspirin, acetaminophen, ibuprofin, 350 milligrams or 500 milligrams, caplets, capsules, and tablets, coated or uncoated. There were 40 options for toothpaste, 150 lipsticks, 75 eyeliners and 90 colors of nail polish from one brand alone. There were 116 kindsof skin cream, and 360 types of shampoo, conditioner, gel, and mousse. Next to them were90 different cold remedies and decongestants. Finally, there was dental floss. Waxed andunwaxed, flavored and unflavored, offered in a variety of thicknesses.
[...]
A typical supermarket carries more than 30,000 items. That’s a lot to choose from. And morethan 20,000 new products hit the shelves every year, almost all of them doomed to failure.

These figures to refer to American supermarkets, but I do think these scenarios count for many other countries as well.

The ambiguous title of this article is The Paradox of Choice 2.0 , the aforementioned supermarket example is analog, if we move such a scenario to the digital world, we get a squared choice overload.
First because online stores like Amazon.com have many titles along the Long Tail terms. Secondly, global is the new local, besides the increased choice related to the books themselves, the amount of e-stores from where a customer can order, has increased drastically as well.
The second explenation of the title is the fact that the Social Web adds a new layer to shopping -opinions- which only will add more to the decision-making paralysis next to the online characteristic.
Due to collaborative filtering, recommendations, opinions, ratings and implicit and explicit personalization tools, customers are getting quality assistance in their decision-making which paradoxically is relevant to their search, but at the same time could be paralyzing in achieving their goal.
Think of Amazon.com which recommends other books in the same category, recommends books which are bought together with a certain book, shows the actual % of people which in the end bought that particular book and the % of people who did buy another one. Next to the recommendations, the large amount of reviews and rating does add value to being well-informed, but does make it harder to decide.

There is a fine balance that C-level and seniors need to find in terms of portfolio, product lines, offer and effects on customer behavior like this, responsibility needs to be taken towards customers in regulating the choice overload.
This is referred to as strategic clarity ,this goes hand in hand with More is Less, where these kind of decisions are not made by businesses and therefore will be emotionally and psychologically detrimental.
Too much is not and won’t be a success factor business-wise and customers will ignore all that is too much, from either perspective too much doesn’t get each of the two further.

How will the two entities -advancing technologies/business and online customer behavior- behave and react to each other now and in the future when the freedom of choice is most probably squared once again?
Will the effect of too much choice reach the top which will negatively impact business or shall strategic clarity diffuse more amongst businesses and prove its importancy?

Busking for Innovation - Tip Jar!

The Paradox of Choice 2.0

Related posts:

  1. The Axiom of Self-Segmentation
  2. Competitors, not Customers, are King
  3. Personalization, Customization, Collaboration – Future Business Trinity
  4. New milestone in Mobile opportunities with ATSC’s Mobile DTV Standard
  5. The Content – Context Diarchy

6 Comments »

  1. Tweets that mention The Paradox of Choice 2.0 | Agora Media Group Blog - Travel Industry, Social TV, tCommerce, 3D, Augmented Reality, Marketing, Design, Applications, Mobile, Open Source -- Topsy.com Says:
    December 31st, 2009 at 12:04 am

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Agora Media Group , Agora Media Group . Agora Media Group said: New blogpost: The Paradox of Choice 2.0: A couple of days ago I was watching a show of a Dutch stand-up comedian, w… http://bit.ly/6G9cJb [...]

  2. Twitted by glcuccureddu Says:
    December 31st, 2009 at 12:33 am

    [...] This post was Twitted by glcuccureddu [...]

  3. uberVU - social comments Says:
    December 31st, 2009 at 12:39 am

    Social comments and analytics for this post…

    This post was mentioned on Twitter by agoramedia: The Paradox of Choice 2.0 http://bit.ly/8wQVHK Choice overload will bring forth decision-making paralysis….

  4. Bram Koster Says:
    December 31st, 2009 at 1:50 pm

    Hi Gianluigi, interesting topic. Have written about the paradox of choice myself earlier this year as well (http://bit.ly/Gmkmt; in Dutch).

    However, since writing that post I ran into this article on the FT website: http://bit.ly/67Ezws. It states that “a more fundamental objection to the “choice is bad” thesis is that the psychological effect may not actually exist at all.” And it goes on to describe the efforts of some scientists to recreate research findings to support the paradox of choice and their failure to do so.

    Interesting stuff to keep an eye out for in the next year!

  5. Gianluigi Cuccureddu Says:
    December 31st, 2009 at 9:16 pm

    @ Bram

    Interesting article indeed.
    In many occassions, theories have ‘two sides’. It is certainly interesting stuff to keep an eye out in 2010, looking forward where it’s heading to, with the Internet and over-choice, clarity is more than welcome.

  6. John Benfield Says:
    January 7th, 2010 at 7:44 pm

    I think that society as a whole is adapting to information, and subsequently choice, overload. While the conclusions of Iyengar and Lepper may have been valid 10 years ago, I think that the whole paradox of choice issue is going away. I beleive that we’re all adapting to the influx of options and information with more agile pattern matching and decision making. It’s most apparent if you watch teenagers reviewing google results, shopping online or evaluating products in a store. It resembles a form of ADD as they flit over irrelevant information, zero in on what’s important to them and make snap decisions while you’re still standing at the door wondering what you’re shopping for.

    There is still an issue of “quality choices”. If someone is unable to easily find a suitable choice, quantity of choices will become irrelevant. But I think that we’re far more willing and able to sift through crap to find diamonds than we’ve ever been in the past.

    I’m sure that if someone did a study segmented by generations and by internet/non-internet users, there would be a pretty distinct split. However, this is all my own opinion and just adds to the available choices of opinion that you can accept or refute :)

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment

Subscribe without commenting

Social Media World Forum

Topics

augmented reality business development communities converged Internet-to-television experience data mining Digital television economics enercities Google Wave hospitality industry hotel industry hotels Innovation innovation agency internet Internet-to-TV experience IPTV linkedin Marketing mCommerce Mobile online online communities open source ORM paladin print media SEM Social Gaming Social Media Social networking Social TV strategy T-Commerce tCommerce technology television 2.0 transactional tv travel industry TV 2.0 Video on demand virtual reality web web 2.0 web media

Linkedin Social TV Group

Join our Linkedin Community:
Social TV Group, Television 2.0, Convergence and Community

Blog Newsletter

Blog Newsletter
* indicates required

View previous campaigns.

Close

Latest Comments

  • Janice Clark on The -real- ROI of Social Media?
  • ROI: Statt Zahlen besser Vertrauen messen - Keshoo? – Tomorrow? – Morgen? on The -real- ROI of Social Media?
  • Dan G on The -real- ROI of Social Media?
  • Annelies on The -real- ROI of Social Media?
  • Gianluigi Cuccureddu on The -real- ROI of Social Media?

Latest Posts

  • The -real- ROI of Social Media?
  • Two Minute Pitch that Helped Push Social TV to the Forefront
  • The Search Engine Advertising Conundrum
  • Why am I not yet sold on the promise of Social TV?
  • Microsoft’s new Augmented Reality Mapping technology

Categories

  • Agora Announcements
  • Augmented Reality – AR
  • Collective Intelligence
  • Industry News
  • Innovation
  • IPTV
  • Management
  • Marketing
  • Mobile
  • Open Source
  • Social Gaming
  • Social Media
  • Social TV
  • T-Commerce

Archives

  • March 2010
  • February 2010
  • January 2010
  • December 2009
  • November 2009
  • October 2009
  • September 2009
  • August 2009

Blog Roll

  • ABI Research - Digital Home Industry Blog
  • Analyst Blogs - David Mercer
  • Andrew Burke's Hardcore IPTV Blog
  • BBC NEWS | dot.life blog
  • Broadband Finder Blog
  • Broadband TV News
  • Connected TV
  • Dean Bubley's Disruptive Wireless
  • Digital-Lifestyles (alpha remix)
  • HDTV UK
  • IPTV News at IPTV Watch
  • Light Reading:
  • paidContent:UK
  • TechRadar: All blogs feeds
  • Telco IPTV View
  • The Digital TV Weblog
  • Under The Rotunda
  • Videonet - news, blogs and analysis for the pay-tv industry - News and Analysis
  • WebsEdge Blog
  • Wired@Home.blog
  • eMarketer
  • Harvard Business Publishing
  • McKinsey Quarterly
  • Strategy+Business
  • The Economist
  • WOMMA
  • Neuromarketing
  • Mass Customization & Open Innovation News
  • Advertising Age
  • Meta

    • Register
    • Log in
    • Entries RSS
    • Comments RSS
    © Copyright Agora Media Group Blog – Travel Industry, Social TV, tCommerce, 3D, Augmented Reality, Marketing, Design, Applications, Mobile, Open Source 2008. All rights reserved.